The kombucha was fizzy and sour and strange. "It's fermented tea," Emma explained. "The SCOBY eats the sugar and produces probiotics." I nodded like I understood what a SCOBY was. I didn't.

But the drink was interesting. Different. I had a second glass. A week later I was still thinking about it.

The SCOBY That Started Everything

Emma grows SCOBYs the way I grow tomatoes—always producing more than she needs. When I mentioned I'd liked the kombucha, she showed up at my cottage with a glass jar containing what looked like a beige pancake floating in amber liquid.

"This is a SCOBY," she said. "Symbiotic Culture of Bacteria and Yeast. You feed it sweet tea, it ferments it into kombucha. Takes about a week."

I stared at the jar. The SCOBY looked alien. Unnatural. "You want me to brew this?"

"Why not? You already know how to make tea."

I've gardened for forty years. I've fixed engines, built furniture, rewired this cottage twice. But standing in my kitchen holding a jar with a living organism I was supposed to feed and maintain felt completely foreign. —  Bill Henderson

Emma walked me through it: brew sweet black tea, let it cool, add the SCOBY and some starter liquid, cover with cloth, wait seven to ten days. "It's really hard to mess up," she said, which I later learned was optimistic.

The First Batch (Disaster)

I followed Emma's instructions exactly. Made the tea too strong because I'm used to coffee. Added too much sugar because I misread the measurement. Put the jar on top of my refrigerator where it was warm, then forgot about it for two weeks.

When I finally remembered, the kombucha was vinegar. Sharp, harsh, completely undrinkable. The SCOBY had grown thick and rubbery. I almost threw the whole thing out.

Tom came by for tomatoes and saw my failed brew. "Too long," he diagnosed. "And probably too much sugar. The SCOBY's fine though—just start over with less tea, less time."

"How do you know about kombucha?" I asked.

"Everyone in these cottages tries it eventually. Emma's very persuasive."

Learning by Failing

Second batch: I checked it every day, tasted it on day seven. Still too sweet. Day eight, day nine. On day ten it tasted right—tangy, slightly fizzy, still recognizable as tea. I'd made something drinkable.

Third batch: I tried bottling it for carbonation. Used wrong bottles. One exploded in my pantry at 2 AM. Woke up thinking someone had broken in. Found glass and kombucha everywhere. Jesse helped me clean up in the morning, laughing the entire time. "Everyone explodes their first batch," he said.

Fourth batch: I bought proper flip-top bottles. Added ginger for flavor like Emma suggested. Too much ginger—tasted like drinking ginger root. Sarah tried it and diplomatically said it was "very gingery."

Fifth batch: Finally got it right. Proper fermentation time, right amount of ginger, good carbonation. I drank a bottle on my back porch and felt absurdly proud of myself.

At seventy-three, I thought I was done learning new skills. Turns out you're never too old to fail at something repeatedly until you figure it out. —  Bill Henderson

What Brewing Taught Me

Kombucha brewing requires patience I don't naturally have. You can't rush fermentation. You can't force it. You check on it, make adjustments, wait. The SCOBY does what it does on its own timeline. All you can do is create good conditions and stay out of the way.

It's also surprisingly forgiving. I've made every mistake possible—wrong temperature, wrong tea, forgotten batches, contaminated jars. The SCOBY keeps working. It grows, reproduces, keeps fermenting. Even my disasters usually produced something drinkable eventually.

But mostly, brewing kombucha became an unexpected entry point into this SILK community. Emma gave me the SCOBY. Tom troubleshot my failures. Jesse commiserated about explosions. Sarah taste-tested experiments. Maya asked for a SCOBY to try herself. Suddenly I was the old guy who brews weird fermented tea, and people stopped by to talk about it.

Six Months Later

I keep four jars going now. One plain, one ginger, one with mixed berries, one experimental batch that's usually questionable. I've given away a dozen SCOBYs. I still drink coffee every morning, but I've switched to kombucha in the afternoon. My digestion's better. My daughter says I seem more adventurous, which is probably code for "weirder."

The kombucha itself is fine—good, even, when I get it right. But what I actually enjoy is the ritual. The brewing, the tending, the patient waiting. The way something alive changes plain sweet tea into something complex and strange. The community of people who understand why I'm excited that my latest batch has exactly the right amount of fizz.

I thought my learning days were behind me. I was wrong. There's always something new to try, some weird hobby to fail at repeatedly until you don't. You just need someone to hand you a jar with a strange blob in it and say, "Why not?"

7 COMMENTS